Sci-Fi Showdown GATE-TO-GATE - Weeks 8 + 9Welcome to the latest edition of the Sci-Fi Showdown.
Unfortunately, I was unable to watch the week 8 episodes in time for a review last week because of a mechanical malfunction on my DVR. However, I have since found other means to watch the episodes, so this week I present to you reviews for both week 8 and 9, in a slightly reduced format to save some time.
Stargate Sg-1 ("Memento Mori")I reckon it was bound to happen eventually, but I just wasn't sure when and how they would handle it. I'm talking about a dedicated Vala (Claudia Black) episode. Since joining the cast full-time this season, such a themed episode was only a matter of time.
In Memento Mori, Vala is kidnapped by the Trust--an international conspiracy group (a.k.a. Sg-1's lamest enemy) being secretly controlled by the Goa'uld. After a botched rescue attempt, Vala's memory is erased, forcing her to wander the streets without a clue.
This episode would probably have been a whole heck of a lot better if I was able to watch it without having to deal with excessive pixel-ization and stuttering sound (thank you very much, Comcast digital cable...), but what little I did see, I liked. There were a few humorous and touching moments--mainly Daniel (Michael Shanks) getting emotional after Vala is thought dead, and when Mitchell (Ben Browder) is tied up to a bed nearly nude.
There was also an unintentionally funny moment in which Mitchell hops on a motorcycle--of course he puts on a helmet so we don't tell that its obviously a stunt-double. But high-speed chases aren't something we see on Sg-1, so for that I found it refreshing.
I feel bad giving this particular episode a rating, as I didn't view it as intended, but I'll do it anyway...
Rating: 8.25/10---
Stargate Sg-1 ("Company of Theives")Like all good Stargate Sg-1 episodes, Company of Theives was packed with plot lines.
After the spaceship Odyssey travels to the supposed location of an Ori super-gate, it is ambushed by forces of the Lucian Alliance (a.k.a. Sg-1's second lamest enemy). With Carter and the crew held hostage, it is up to Daniel, Vala, and Mitchell and Teal'c to find and rescue them.
The first thing I noticed about this episode was the edited opening sequence. I usually don't pay much attention to Sg-1 opener, but something strange caught my eye towards the end. With Vala (Claudia Black) now a full-time member of Sg-1, they have spliced her running up to the 'Gate to meet the rest of the cast. I'll admit, I laughed a little. Certainly didn't expect it.
As per the episode, it was a fine rollercoaster ride of emotions. From the emotional death of a side character to the return of a bumbling alien race, there was plenty to keep me interested. And although I've never been a big fan of the Lucian Alliance plot lines, the in-depth look at the organization in this episode was better than I expected.
Best part of the episode came at the end, however. In one of the better "oh shi-" moments I've seen in a while, a doomed alien cowls, "Damn you, Cam Mitchell!" Just classic.
Rating: 8.5/10---
Stargate Atlantis ("McKay and Mrs. Miller")After this episode failed to properly record on my DVR, I will admit that I had considered simply skipping it. However, I'm quite glad that I didn't. Keeping in line with the rest of Atlantis' 3rd season, this episode was a real winner.
In McKay and Mrs. Miller, Rodney (David Hewlett) ventures back to Earth in order to meet with his estranged sister. In a surge of inspiration, she developed a complex mathematical theory--one that could solve Atlantis' energy problems. However, after their experiment begins to destroy an alternate dimension, its resident McKay travels to our dimension, leading to hilarious results.
As far as Atlantis comedy is concerned, it doesn't get any better than this episode. It had it all...Rodney/Carter interaction, funny Rodney backstory, Hermiod doing what he does, an alternate, cool Rodney named 'Rod'--really anything involving Rodney was golden in this episode. This only further reinforces my belief that David Hewlett is Atlantis' strongest cast member.
Funny as all get out and even a little touching, McKay and Mrs. Miller deserves Atlantis Best-Of status.
Rating: 9.5/10---
Stargate Atlantis ("Phantoms")This episode was a real trip. Well written and executed, it proves that Atlantis is just as capable at delivering drama as it is comedy.
In Phantoms, the Atlantis team ventures to a planet searching for another team that failed to report back. There they find the remains of several Genii, who had apparently killed each other. After McKay discovers a mysterious Wraith generator device, the team is attacked by a deranged survivor. Now McKay must find a way to turn off the device and its brain-altering effects before the Atlantis team turn on each other.
The real stand-out performance of this episode goes to leading man Joe Flanigan. As part of his hallucination, he imagines himself back in the deserts of Afghanistan, fighting for his life against Taliban soldiers. Real-world conflict isn't presented much in the Stargate franchise, so it was interesting to see how the writers would handle it. I was impressed. The added backstory to the Sheppard character is also a great contribution to the already complex lead role.
I would also be amiss if I failed to mention Paul McGillion's performance as Dr. Beckett. Coping with his fading sanity while trying to save a wounded soldier was Atlantis drama at its best. The good doctor seems to be joining the Atlantis team more and more lately, which I think is ultimately a good thing. I would be pleased if McGillion became a regular team member.
Rating: 8.5/10Thus concludes this jam-packed edition of The Sci-Fi Showdown. Be sure to check back next Monday when I review the Sg-1 and Atlantis mid-season finales. You won't want to miss it.
~Khyron, 2006